“Let’s play a game and you scream at me and stuff.” Classic.

Openly gay and hilarious Billy on the Street comedian Billy Eichner made his first appearance on The Late Show and, after receiving the above instruction from David Letterman, proceeded to yell his way through an absurd game called “Celebrity Child or Kentucky Derby Winner?” Pilot Inspector? War Admiral? Blue Angel? Moxie Crime Fighter? It is shockingly impossible to win.

The results are laugh-out-loud funny, and it is clear that Eichner’s caustic brand of comedy has a new fan in Letterman. “Do you have any more games we can play? I just like being yelled at! It’s exciting,” says Letterman, and with Eichner in command it’s hard not to believe him.

Check it out, AFTER THE JUMP…